I am here at Digital Identity World and this morning and early afternoon we had a great Identity Open Space preceding it. We had a great range of talks. I lead introductory primer about the whole user-centric identity landscape. It was followed by primers throughout the day on technical elements – Microsoft’s Cards space, Open Source Identity Selector, , I-names/XRI, OpenID, Higgins, and more social elements Trust and Reputation, Identity Commons, Identity and schema mapping.
Event
Return to the 'default world'
The experience at Burning Man is really undescribable.
Organizers bill the festival as “an annual experiment in temporary community dedicated to radical self-expression and radical self-reliance.” I guess this as good way to think about it.
There are so many ways that it is radically different then the ‘default world’ that it just becomes hard to explain. I have many friends and aquaintances who have been to Burning Man or are Burners (people who self identify as part of the community and go again and again). I guess I never really sat any of them down to ask ‘what is it like’ I had a few impressions based on tidbits I had heard about but it was really just out of this world.
Trees – The first thing I did when we stopped at a rest stop on our way to Reno from Burning Man was to hug a tree. There are none of those in the desert except flaming mettle ones. It was just so amazing to see this life growing out of the earth. When I got home I marvlled at the flowers in our yard and the vines on our fence.
Earth – The earth at burning man is really present. The Playa is flat and present. You can’t help but feel the earth. The techno and music going kind of creates this beat that you feel from her. I was awake early for sun rise on Sunday morning. It was amazing with the cathedral gave an extra sort of awe to the whole sun rising experience. The feelings evoked were deep indescribable making tears well up.
Little bits of Magic – That morning I decided to go all the way out to Hope street and bikc back along the outside. Between 2:00 and 7:00 there is walk in camping along the edges. This is one place to camp if you want quite way out on the edge. I biked along found this little sanctuary. It was just a normal tent you might find in a famers market. It had underneith it a white carpet and a white couch (that was an old car back car seet) and several lovely white pillows. A white table and with a buddha in the middle. They had drapped wide white cloth streamers hanging down from the edges and a wind chime hung in the middle. The white streamers where waving in the wind and the chime dinged away…like little fairy bells. I was very tired and decided to stop and rest on the pillows for about half an hour it was lovely. It was these sort of spontanious goodnesses that just seem to be normal here that make Burning Man so great.
Navigation on the Playa – Burning Man is laid out in a circle . I really loved orienting to things this way. It gets you out of the ‘grid’ of the default world and gets you thinking organically. In the middle is ‘The Man’ at 12 o’clock is the temple and at 6 o’clock is center camp. At 3 o’clock and 9 o’clock there is a path out to the man and within the streets a circle of theme camps. Camping happens between 10:00 and 2:00. The space between 10 and 2 extends out into ‘deep plya’ and is where much of the art is. The street facing the Man is called the Esplnad. It is like a promonade where a lot of the evening activities happen. Then there was Anxious, Brave, Chance, Destiny, Eager, Fate, Guess, Hope. All addresses had a ‘time’ location and a Street.
Mutant Vehicles – Their are no normal cars at Burning Man. They are wonderously different. There are 30 foot high motorized tricycles, bunny rabbit vans, carrot cars, motorized couches, clouds, so many…you almost never see the same one twice. Out here in the default world they seem so boring. If you have a vision of a car…this is a great place to make it for and drive around for a week. Just get it approved by the Department of Mutant Vehicals.
Theme Camps range vastly relfecting a wide diversity if human experience and interest. Math Camp was for Mathematicians, Evolutionary Center was folks working with evolutionary consiousness, Pancake playhouse served pancakes every morning, the list goes on and on and on….
My Theme Camp – Sustainabilaville I stayed in Sustainabilaville at 8:15 and Eager. We had a tower made out of scafolding 5 high. Hanging from that was aluminet fabric that was invented in Israel to protect crops from the sun. We had 50% block for our morning light and 75% blog for the afternoon. On either side we had costco barns – one for the kitchen the other for our vanity and cloths. Our tents were under the morning side of the lilluminet and on the afternoon side facing the street we had a great living room area.
Identity on the Playa. This is really interesting. Most folks have a playa name – they range from Ra to Alphabetty, to . One of the reasons for this is that messages written in the playa info system are all publically avaliable on the web. One might participate in life activities on the playa that one does not want tied back to ones ‘default’ world name.
Resourcefulness and Creativity– Everyone brings all they need to survive for a week on the Playa. Food, Water and other Supplies. The only thing you can buy at Burning Man are Ice from ‘antarctica’ and coffee or tea at the Center Camp. Other then this no cash changes hands on the Playa. This makes for an interesting week..no cash yet total abundance and creativity. People gift each other all kinds of things, stickers, bandanas, CD’s, food, music, art.
I would totally recommend Going to Burning Man if you can. I am going to work on organizing a theme camp near sustainabiliaville (based on there successful model of ‘how to do an oasis in the desert) for folks in the Planetwork and Identity communities who would like to go – go together. Feel free to ping me if you are interested.
The things that might bug you and how to deal with them on the Playa.
Dust. No question the playa is a dusty place. Water is a precious and not really bantied about as it is in regular life. Never leave camp without your googles and dust mask. you never know when a dust storm will pick up. If you have these two things you will be fine.
If you really want an escape from the dust you could rent an RV. To me this is a sort of cop out from actually being in the Playa. RV’s have showers.
You can set up your own shower and have a grey water evaporation system to avoid hauling all the water you used off the playa.
The one thing that was just great and basically helped me stay clean the whole time was (clorine free) baby wipes. Just use two of those to wipe your whole body down and you are clean as you need to be. Bring moisturizer and use it liberally. Minimize the exposure of your feet the Playa.
You can augment any of the above once every few days running behind one of the trucks that drives by spraying water on the roads to keep the dust down. (the problem with this is you have to hear a truck coming strip down in time and run behind the truck….down side your feet get way muddy.)
Porto-poties.
You know I was sort of dreading porto-potying for a week but was surprised. The contractors are really on top of keeping up with the traffic as it where, so they were really not that bad. They had germ gel to squirt on your hands after you go.
Nudity and Sex You have to be ok with seeing people naked – men and women. Having said that most people are not naked all the time. It is not uncommon to see penis shapes protruding from art cars or guys just wearing extra penis/balls on there costumes. I saw at least two guys dressed up as big penis’. Women walk around topless too and even nude. After a few days all of this sort of just recedes into the background and you can basically ignore it. It is sort of obvious where the sex and fetish camps are – if you aren’t into that stuff don’t go to their camps. There is so much more happening in Burning Man…you will find plenty of other interesting things to do.
Be prepared to be continually fascinated by new things. They come out of everywhere. All over. After a week of my return I find myself a week later looking at the world with a renewed sence of wonder – almost child like but perhaps more deeply conscious then that.
Away Again
I had a wonderful time at Foo Camp. The OpenID meeting yesturday was interesting. Identity Commons call this morning went well. Lots to blog about but I am off to the Plya now. So I look forward seeing all at the Identity Open Space (register now if you have not done so yet … if you don’t we can’t order you lunch) and Digital Identity World. It should be a fantastic show.
What is your title…mine is Identity Woman
So I am back from the Art of Leadership at HollyHock that was both a vacation and a bit of work. While I was away the announcement went out about a conference I agreed to speak at about identity in October – Office 2.0.
I didn’t really have time to do a bio while off retreating and I pointed them to my broad “who I am” page at kaliyasblogs. In reading this they picked up on a positional title I had and decided to list me with that just linking to Identity Woman under the blog link (without mentioning it in text). I find this odd because Ismael asked me to speak at the conference because I am Identity Woman.
From IT Redux: Kaliya’s participation should help us understand if there is a chance that we could get single sign-on for Office 2.0 in our lifetimes.
I would like to ask all the folks who blogged about the upcoming conference to list me as “Kaliya Hamlin aka Identity Woman, Network Director Planetwork”.
I find it interesting there is such a focus on that positional title to have legitimacy in this industry. I really think it is a disservice all around there are people who contribute a lot without positional ‘titles’ who deserve to be on stage some times perhaps more then those on stage who have ‘titles’. I hope we as a community can look at this bias towards ‘titles’ and reflect on the unique gifts and talents that are not being recognized because of it.
Think about it. If you can change my title listing on your blogs…thanks 🙂
Criag
Ross
Rob
David
Woodrow
BlogHer and Microsoft Live….
I have lots to say about BlogHer – and will be sharing it over the next few weeks. It was quite an emotional event for me on a bunch of levels. With all the buzz about Microsoft is launching Windows Live Spaces tonight I thought I would chime in on that aspect of BlogHer.
Basically I was completely turned off what ever they might be doing in there space by the “BE JANE” skit at BlogHer.
Amy Gahran sums it up:
“Still, I had to cringe at the campy, off-target Microsoft presentation during the welcome session just a few minutes ago.
To promote its new Windows Live Spaces service, someone at Microsoft thought it would be appropriate and fun to send a couple of bouncy, bubbly, sexy, carefully scripted 20-somethings uniformed in tight t-shirts and jeans to banter giddily for about 10 minutes on home improvement. It sounded like Barbie doing ‘Tool Time’ in stereo.”
Teachermama also had thoughts:
All around me, people were making comments about feeling like ‘Math is hard’ Barbie was up on stage talking WAY down to us. Here’s a hint: if you’re facing a ballroom full of hundreds of smart, tech-savvy women, ‘home improvement is scary’ isn’t the way to our hearts.”
I know some great people at MSFT – Kim Cameron, Lilly Chang and some other great folks who are actually the best human being marketer types you could imagine – Brady who just left for O’Reilly, Liz Lawley who just left after her sabbatical year there and of course the biggest loss of all – Scoble.
Imagine how cool MSFT’s blogging tools platform and approach could have been if they had just listened to the people who get it and have a relationship to the community (like Scoble who instead he is off making PodTech cool).
Note to Balmer – stop letting the good people you have go and stop putting the marketing morons in charge. And for god sakes don’t fuck up the messaging around Vista, Cardspace and Identity. I think we need to have an intensive heart to heart with the identity community and your marketing ‘army’ before things roll out.
Some folks like Kevin O’Keefe at Lexblog picked up on this, and gave some constructive feedback –
Microsoft “should have gone the low key approach as at Gnomedex. Write a check to a worthwhile program, get thanked on various occasions, and get out of the way.”
On the up side….Kim just blogged this…
An unequivocal Yes: Windows Live ID will accept third party authentication for access to Microsoft properties.
OpenID2 Developer Info Day Aug 10th Bay Area
I am really pleased to announce that we have an
OpenID Informational Evening for Developers
August 10th 6-9 in Berkeley at 2029 University, Upstairs.
The Big news is the community has converged and figured out the authentication layer – OpenID…OpenID is just the authentication layer – but on top of this ad hoc standard lots of cool stuff can happen. The goal of the evening is not to geek out on identity but to connect with a developers working on applications that require users to login.
Find out more about what it is…how it works…how you can install. The incentives to learn are high with the $5000 bounty for having OpenID in Open Source projects.
Presenting and answering Questions
David Recordon formerly of Live Journal/Six Appart now of Verisign will be presenting a bit about the origins of OpenID but most importantly how it works…and how you install it.
Andy Dale from ooTao will talk a bit about i-names and how they work with OpenID2 and looking forward to what comes next after authentication – profile sharing. ooTao is also data sharing are running ibroker services.
Mary Hodder CEO of Dabble will talk about the work happening around the development of itags.
I am helping coordinate the evening please RSVP to me – kaliya (at) Mac (dot) com and feel free to ask me any questions.
If you know a developer – pass the word along.
ps. for all you Technorati guys who keep having questions…now is your chance to ask the guys who know.
UPDATE: Scott Keveton from JanRain will be there too…He just posted an OpenID walk through on his site.
UPDATE 2:Dick Hardt from Sxip will be in town and will also be joining us for the evening. Hopefully he will share some of the cool stuff sxip is doing with OpenID.
OSCON 06 Day 5 – cxap is launched
Today opened with a great talk about the history of the IBM PC. Dave Bradley the advice I liked was ‘choose your partners carefully‘ and ‘small decisions may last forever‘ -he was talking about a 5 hour meeting with 3 people that created the character set that is now ‘the official standard.’
————
Technology trend spotting by Roger Magoulas the research director at O’Reilly was sort of interesting but why? What are the trends coming besides rails and ajax.
————
We had an ok presentation about a really important topic – hacking government by Carl Malamud.
The real danger that Tim O’Reilly highlights those who have the power to make the laws/regulations not understanding the realm in which they make those rools.
ITU world summit on information technology – for starters the ‘corspondent’ from O’Reilly could not get ‘press credentials to attend. WHAT! They were talking about Internet Governance and their are noises about another governance body for the web emerging by those ‘heads of state’.
Hack2: Get Standing Join the operation
He highlighted the Smithsonian – Showtime Network issue (they signed a 30 year exclusive agreement with the network limiting there ability to put content up in other forms.
Hack3: Be Governmnet
put more of what is happening in government online and support annotation – They are working on launching the Public Memory Trust starting with the Washington Bridge to have 18 hearings running simoltaniously online. There exit strategy – Make the Government Do it.
Hack4: Mirror the FCC
Hack5: Enforce ODF open document format
Hack6: Audit Validity (for disabilities)
Hack7: Rank by Bad Links (links on government pages are notoriously stale)
Hack8: Annotate Hearings
Hack9: Hold Hearings
Hack10: Map Spectrum
he said that only 2% of the spectrum is actually used and that we as the hacker community could map spectrum and make a case for opening up the spectrum our common resources.
Skills using for builing open source are citizenship skills for the common good. To resist private interest taking over government
___________
OpenTalk 2.0 Maximizing non-stakeholder buy-in by leveraging departed Generic informaiton transfer protocols
Damian Conway gave an amazing presentation about OpenTalk 2.0 – cxap. This presentation was even better because on on day 0 of OSCON – sunday he gave a presentation on presentations to speakers. In this talk he basically in this presentation made fun of presentations and did everything you are not supposed to do in presentations….
Zak Greant’s summary –
Damien Conway’s is giving the funniest public whipping I have ever seen. He is simulatenously kicking the ass of Web 2.0, Sxip, patents, patent vulture firms, snake oil crypto, Microsoft, Google, r0ml and the rest of us all at the same time.
Great quotes include:
- We have a patent on replacing the letter in a name with x, but still pronouncing it the same way.
- Every time you read the name Microsoft, you will see a kitten. We call it “Pavlovian Marketing”
- We thought that we might call it … firefly, fireangel, firebuffy. Then it became obvious – the new browser is called FireWhedon.
Idnetity at OSCON
For those of you joining identity folks – me, Doc Searls, David Recordon, Dick Hardt, Drummond Reed, Scott Kveton, Larry Drebes Dave Kearns, Scott Mace here at OSCON there will be a few opportunities to learn more about what we all have been up to.
1) At OSCAMP tomorrow the OpenID convergence folks plan on runing a session in the afternoon tomorrow approximately 1:30 – 3:00.
2) David Recordon has a session on Practical OpenID in OSCON proper on friday 10:45 – 11:30.
I am going to propose that we have a sheet at OSCAMP that says ask the identity folks a question so you can ‘ping us’ in meet space – while at OSCON. We can have more sessions during OSCamp on what you want to know about. I will list them here as I know about them.
Exciting week coming up….
This week in Vancouver is going to be great. It has started out fantastic so far:
Getting here: Brian and I flew up here on a $125 flight (it would normally be over $200 between SFO and Vancouver) that included a steak dinner with wine in economy class and the freedom to watch any one of 40 movies. It secret – Quantus Airlines. I recomend this new found strategy for getting around North America fly on International Airlines doing hops.
Vancouver Folk Music Festival: The festival is as old as I am 🙂 and I went every year pretty much until I left for college in 1995. It feels so good to be back there. The music is lovely. The best performers last night were Dubblestandart a dub music group from Viena. They also had a very enjoyable Bhangra Celebration. Vancouver into embracing its Asianness as a city and this is another example of that. Here are flickr phots of the main stage etc.
It was also super interesting that federated labour, COPE, BC Nurses Union, BC Government Employees Union, BC Teachers Federation all had advertisements in the show brochure. Unions here are mainstream and middle class a fundamental part of the fabric of canadian life.
The one bad part was buying tickets online. The process was not clear and they didn’t send a follow up e-mail to confirm purchase. I had thought my first transaction did not go through so we bought tickets again. It turns out it had gone through – if they had sent confirmation e-mails I would have known.
Coming up:
Social Tech Brewing in Vancouver: Katrin Verclas the new Executive Director of NTEN (Nonprofit Technology Enterprise Network) will be in town and having a dinner. I am very glad that she is holding this ‘border-busting conversation‘.
Liberty Alliance Meetings: on Tuesday and Wednesday should be great to see what goes on in inside. I will be under NDA so I can’t really talk about it but I will be able to share a sense of what it is like energetically.
Identity Open Space: on Thursday and Friday is going to be fantastic. Lots of great folks are coming to participate. I am excited several friends are coming up from Seattle who work in Tech and Social good.
My Family: I am enjoying hanging out with my Aunt and will get to talk more with my cousin at a dinner they are putting together for his birthday. He is 14 and super super into World of Warcraft. He doesn’t like school. I hope we can talk to him about the computer industry and how he might make a living in it given his proclivity towards them.
5 Identity Sessions at MashupCamp
Johannes Earnst, David Recordon, John Clippinger, Jon Ramer and myself were all there.
Access Control for Federation.
Aggregating Profile Data
Identity, security, access control, social networking: there’s got to be (and there is) a better way than more user names and passwords
Access Controls Part 2
I-Card and Higgins (not posted on the wiki yet)
Unconferences get mainstream coverage
The San Jose Mercury News covered MashupCamp on the front page of the Business Section today. I blogged about the article on my Unconference Blog. They had the title in the paper – “How can you plan anything in Silicon Valley using these rules?”
Identity at MashupCamp
I am at MashupCamp2 today facilitating. It is really fun to get up there and help 300+ folks make their own agenda for the day. The energy in the room is fantastic. People were asking me to encourage the sessions to be more spread out cause they wanted to go like to 4 different discussions proposed in one time slot.
Johannes Ernst and David Recordon are hear and there are at least two different sessions around identity on the schedule. I am in the first session being lead by Johannes scoping out the problem set and around identity and mashups.
Technorati Tags: identity, MashupCamp, mashupcamp2, unconference
Wow! – Todays Surprise I was on stage at Gnomedex.
The audience did a shout out for who would lead the the “MVP” discussion here at Gnomedex. They picked me. This has got to be one of the highlights of my career so far. I was handed the mic and invited on stage (right then) to lead a discussion for 15min. Thanks to Dave and Marc for their vocal support.
I used the opportunity to talk about the gap that I see between the civil society – (the group forming network that has been a foundational part of america – DeTocqueville wrote about it) and the social tool building sector. There is a massive gap. I hope that we can find ways to bridge it.
The reason that I am involved in the Identity world is because I want to see people, the citizens in civil society be empowered. I highlighted at the end the potential to weave together – MircoAps to meet their community needs. Where is the “myspace” for churches? Where are the social network tools to augment the neighborhood or a city block mailing list? I hope this community can engage with my challenge to them.
The identity stuff is happening right now big time. There is the Identity Open Space in Vancouver July 20-21. and in Santa Clara Sept 11.
I put forward that several things – there are a few organizations in the intersection –
• Planetwork (where I am the Network Director) We are working on the 1Society Project to build open source open standards based reference architecture for the identity layer working for civil society.
InterraProject – local economy loyalty card and social networking for community.
• The Nonprofit Technology Enterprise Network
• Compumentor (Net2)
• Aspiration (They have the Advocacy Dev III coming up at the end of the month).
Other things that came up during the conversation:
Today we talked about lifestyle businesses and success beyond the ‘massive liquidity event’. These are the kinds of companies that can fulfill the huge array of niches. There is an enormous market to serve civil society group forming networks.
There were some people talking about how ‘we don’t need tools’ – everything is fine or that online tools are really just good for interest communities that are not geographic.
Susan Mernit stood up and said to those being contrarian should listen to what I was saying – for those of us who care about open source we should make sure these tools work for civil society. The big companies – Microsoft etc. are making life management tools and we as a community should be thinking about them too.
Technorati Tags: Aspiration, civilsociety, community, conference, gnomedex, gnomedex6, identity, IdentityOSVan, Net2, nptech, NTEN, puppy, women
Exciting Day for User-Centric Identity
Tomorrow the 20th of June at 7pm we are opening the global registry for i-names. This was announced a few weeks ago by the XDI.org board. There will be 7 initial ibrokers 6 of whom are opening there doors tomorrow. There is a great site explaining i-names broadly for people and organizations along with a developer site. Cordance (Drummond Reed’s company) has a new website up too articulating its pioneering role in brining user centric, privacy protecting digital addresses to the market 🙂
This day is a big day for many folks who have been working on this for various lengths of time (any where from 14 years to several months). I began working in the identity space first with the very early alpha experiment that Planetwork did for its 2004 conference. While preparing for that conference (which I worked to evangelize for) I had my first “identity woman” experience about 10 guys gathered to figure out how to kluge several systems together this identity stuff together and all day I listened – learning a lot and said one thing all day. At the end of the day we took a picture and I was the only woman there.
At the conference I was hired by Owen and the Identity Commons (1.0)along with Jan Hauser to work on driving adoption of these new tools in civil society. I was thinking today while talking to Bill Washburn saying that I didn’t think we would be meeting today at Harvard on all these topics if it had not been for Owen’s significant visionary personal investment in the vision of this new identity layer – that really empowered people. The specifics of that early program never came to fruition in exactly the way originally envisioned but the results have been demonstrable in many ways. So tomorrow if you get a chance be sure to say THANK YOU! Owen.
Yesterday, Monday the 19th was a big day with this proposal put forward to the Apache Foundation to become a project there.
The project would start with Yadis for URL/XRI-based service discovery, OpenID for web based single-sign-on and the basis of exchanging profile data, and to create a desktop component with a standard look and feel, ideally working with the Open Source Identity Selector (OSIS) project.
Technorati Tags: community, conference, cordance, Identitycommons, idmashup06, inames, interoperability, OwenDavis, Reputation, Women, Women2.0
Harvard through Canadian Eyes
Landing in in Cambridge at Harvard today for the start of the ‘identity Mashup‘. The experience of east coast norms of ‘elitism’ have been something that I have had to acclimatize to as I come out here to go to events and conferences. It also is something that rubs up against my “west coast” and “Canadian egalitarianism.” Malcome Gladwell a Canadian and author of The Tipping POint and Blink, captures the subtle world view difference in his recent essay in the New Yorker “Getting In” The article is long but I have exerted here if you want to get the gist of his thesis.
Here is the main thesis from the end of the article in case you don’t want to read to the end.
Élite schools, like any luxury brand, are an aesthetic experience—an exquisitely constructed fantasy of what it means to belong to an élite —and they have always been mindful of what must be done to maintain that experience.
Some quotes from the beginning of the essay…
There was, first of all, that strange initial reluctance to talk about the matter of college at all—a glance downward, a shuffling of the feet, a mumbled mention of Cambridge. “Did you go to Harvard?” I would ask. I had just moved to the United States. I didn’t know the rules. An uncomfortable nod would follow. Don’t define me by my school, they seemed to be saying, which implied that their school actually could define them. And, of course, it did.
What is this “Harvard” of which you Americans speak so reverently?
By the nineteen-sixties, Harvard’s admissions system had evolved into a series of complex algorithms. The school began by lumping all applicants into one of twenty-two dockets, according to their geographical origin. (There was one docket for Exeter and Andover, another for the eight Rocky Mountain states.)
Social scientists distinguish between what are known as treatment effects and selection effects. The Marine Corps, for instance, is largely a treatment-effect institution. It doesn’t have an enormous admissions office grading applicants along four separate dimensions of toughness and intelligence. It’s confident that the experience of undergoing Marine Corps basic training will turn you into a formidable soldier. A modelling agency, by contrast, is a selection-effect institution. You don’t become beautiful by signing up with an agency. You get signed up by an agency because you’re beautiful.
At the heart of the American obsession with the Ivy League is the belief that schools like Harvard provide the social and intellectual equivalent of Marine Corps basic training—that being taught by all those brilliant professors and meeting all those other motivated students and getting a degree with that powerful name on it will confer advantages that no local state university can provide.
The extraordinary emphasis the Ivy League places on admissions policies, though, makes it seem more like a modeling agency than like the Marine Corps, and, sure enough, the studies based on those two apparently equivalent students turn out to be flawed.
You are whom you admit in the élite-education business, and when Harvard changed whom it admitted, it changed Harvard.
The Ivy League schools justified their emphasis on character and personality, however, by arguing that they were searching for the students who would have the greatest success after college. They were looking for leaders, and leadership, the officials of the Ivy League believed, was not a simple matter of academic brilliance. “Should our goal be to select a student body with the highest possible proportions of high-ranking students, or should it be to select, within a reasonably high range of academic ability, a student body with a certain variety of talents, qualities, attitudes, and backgrounds?
Harvard didn’t want lots of relatively happy and successful graduates. It wanted superstars,
This is, in no small part, what Ivy League admissions directors do. They are in the luxury-brand-management business, and “The Chosen,” in the end, is a testament to just how well the brand managers in Cambridge, New Haven, and Princeton have done their job in the past seventy-five years.
Harvard wants good graduates, and part of their definition of a good graduate is someone who is a generous and loyal alumnus. And if you want generous and loyal alumni you have to reward them. Aren’t the tremendous resources provided to Harvard by its alumni part of the reason so many people want to go to Harvard in the first place? The endless battle over admissions in the United States proceeds on the assumption that some great moral principle is at stake in the matter of whom schools like Harvard choose to let in—that those who are denied admission by the whims of the admissions office have somehow been harmed. If you are sick and a hospital shuts its doors to you, you are harmed. But a selective school is not a hospital, and those it turns away are not sick. Élite schools, like any luxury brand, are an aesthetic experience—an exquisitely constructed fantasy of what it means to belong to an élite —and they have always been mindful of what must be done to maintain that experience.
Technorati Tags: conference, Freedom, identity, idmasshup06, idmashup06
Citizen Action Team – distributed disaster help matching
One of the most impressive things that I saw at the Organizers Collaborative Conference was the Citizen Action Team. In the wake of Katrina they build a Ruby on Rails Database to match donors offerings of help to groups and institutions who need help. The demoed the database and it was really impressive.
We are a politically unaffiliated, independent group of volunteers that have come together to provide supplies to folks of the hurricane ravaged Gulf coastline. We are serving the least served areas. We are working directly with shelter relief teams in areas such as Lafayette and Baton Rouge, LA, Gulfport and Hattiesburg, MS .
This list will grow as we pin-point and identify needs of other under-served, under-supplied pop-up shelters in the most needy areas. Our campaign begins by establishing need, supplying the basics and then gauging what next will most aid “our” shelters. With efficiency tempered by compassion, we stay in close contact, following donations from collection to distribution. We have established warehouse operations in Lafayette, Gulfport and are now developing other locations.
Hopefully in the next big disaster there will be a real digital addressing infrastructure working to make it even more efficient.
Mark Dixon – Best summary of Catalyst
Identity Gang meeting Catalyst
We had a great Identity Gang meeting at 7am yesturday morning at Burton Group Catalyst. Paul put forward doing a Lexicon 2.0 to define some new things. He got some volunteers to help with that and is looking for more if you are interested.
Paul and I shared the news about Identity Commons “2.0” moving forward in forming a nonprofit structure. The purpose is to support the many working groups in the community having a common wiki and other infrastructure.
Catalyzing Hospitality night one
The Hospitality suites were once again fun this year. I thought I would hand out some ‘awards’:
I think First Prize goes to Novell for their Star Trek theme. The whole room was spacey covered in fabric with pinpoints of light. They had live spacy groovy yet ambient music. I have a 1 min video of it here.
Fun and Engaging goes to the ActiveIdentity San Fransico Idol Suite with Karaoke. Eve Maler and I did a duet (sort of – I was back up). Later on in the evening William Hung gave a performance too.
Theme aligned with Name of company for the second year in the row goes to Element – for their Earth Wind Water Fire Theme complete with the ICE Bar and dramatic ‘elemental’ video on the wall.
Women are lovely. I am not against them helping out in a hospitality suite that are after all supposed to be fun. There are all sorts of ways to employ their help in tasteful and respectful ways. So these to awards are a pair –
- Lovely Lady Suite Support is a tie going to the Horse Racing lady and the Nascar recruiter. There work was captured on video.
- Worst Booth Babe goes to Layer Seven for this lovely number in a very reveling mini skirt propositioning people to come to their wine tasting in the hall way. Runner up goes to passlogic.
Worst Theme to build trust goes to IBM for Alcatraz Prison “Hotel” complete with the IBM staff being prison guards or perhaps prisoners.
Bland goes to Microsoft Apparently didn’t get “MARKETING” involved in anyway with its room. It had Italian food in the middle and booths of all these different companies sharing how they were all working together. Ping, and Sun among them.
Technorati Tags: BoothBabes, BurtonGroup, Catalyst, Element, IBM, Microsoft, nacatalyst06, Novell, HospitalitySuites, puppy, Women, xmlgrrl
THE WORD: Managiziation
Mike Neuenschwander gave a GREAT performance this morning. Last year he destroyed a guitar on stage and assured us that it had a good life in guitar heaven. This year he brought us THE WORD: Managization. I captured it using my camera’s video function. You can check it out over on my Vlog.
Technorati Tags: BurtonGroup, Catalyst, identity, nacatalyst06
Mashup Banking a no go – says Jamie Lewis
This morning’s opening session at Catalyst was great.
Jamie talked about a range of issues including the Inconvenient truths.
That stronger authentication by itself will not make us more secure. All Authentication is dependent on assurance that is a human process and is vulnerable to low tech attacks.
He highlighted the fact that identity management and particularly as it moves into the web is very much a social problem.
The fact that much of the Web 2.0 crowd was going towards simpler protocols was happening but also that these tools would not really work in the context of online banking….
Mashups and Banking just don’t go together.





